News, Analysis, Trends, Management Innovations for
Clinical Laboratories and Pathology Groups

Hosted by Robert Michel

News, Analysis, Trends, Management Innovations for
Clinical Laboratories and Pathology Groups

Hosted by Robert Michel
Sign In

Iranian Study Shows Staggering Carcinogenic Risk in Hospital Laboratories from Occupational Exposure to Deadly Chemicals

Study found highest incidences of occupational carcinogenesis among clinical laboratory and histology technicians, followed by pathologists

It has been known for years that formalin (a form of formaldehyde used as a disinfectant and preservative in the handling of tissues samples in anatomy, pathology, and microbiology labs), as well as xylene and toluene, are dangerous to clinical laboratory workers. Nations around the world have taken steps to minimize exposure to these dangerous chemicals. However, a recent study in Iran found that those measures may not have gone far enough to protect histology and clinical laboratory technicians, pathologists, and medical laboratory scientists.

The study conducted by researchers in the Department of Occupational Health Engineering, School of Public Health, at Tehran University of Medical Sciences, showed that levels of exposure to these chemicals is still significantly higher than recommended, resulting in a higher risk for cancer among lab workers in Iran’s hospitals.

The scientists published their findings in the journal Nature Scientific Reports titled, “Occupational Exposure, Carcinogenic and Non-Carcinogenic Risk Assessment of Formaldehyde in the Pathology Labs of Hospitals in Iran.”

“Employing risk assessment techniques as a complementary tool in monitoring programs for respiratory exposure in the different work setting should be considered to protect the staffs against both non-cancerous and cancer-related hazards,” the study authors wrote.

Lessons learned from the Iranian hospital lab study could benefit clinical laboratory workers in US hospitals and help those who work with formaldehyde, toluene, and xylene worldwide to reduce their chances of developing a vascular condition known as Raynaud’s phenomenon (shown above) which can lead to necrosis and gangrene, as well as other dangerous health conditions affecting the lungs, brain, and other systems and organs in the body. (Photo copyright: Wikipedia.)

Study Details

The Iranian study considered the carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic impact of occupational exposure to formaldehyde in the pathology laboratories of four Tehran hospitals. The researchers “used a quantitative risk assessment method proposed by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), along with its provided database known as the Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS). Respiratory symptoms were assessed using the American Thoracic Society (ATS) questionnaire,” the study authors wrote in Nature Scientific Reports.

The scientists found that “91.23% of exposure levels in occupational groups exceed the NIOSH [National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health] standard of 0.016 ppm.” They determined that “41.03% of all the studied subjects were in the definite carcinogenic risk range (LCR > 10−4), 23.08% were in the possible carcinogenic risk range (10−5 < LCR < 10−4), and 35.90% were in the negligible risk range (LCR < 10−6),” they wrote.

“The highest index of occupational carcinogenesis was observed in the group of lab technicians with a risk number of 3.7 × 10-4, followed by pathologists with a risk number of 1.7 × 10-4,” the scientists wrote. “Furthermore, 23.08% of the studied subjects were within the permitted health risk range (HQ < 1.0), while 76.92% were within the unhealthy risk range (HQ > 1.0),” they added.

“Formaldehyde exhibits high solubility in water and is rapidly absorbed by the nasal cavity, sinuses, throat, and mucous membrane of the upper respiratory tract upon exposure,” the study authors wrote. “Consequently, due to the elevated potential for both carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic formaldehyde exposure among pathology staff—particularly laboratory technicians—the implementation of management measures … becomes imperative to lower the exposure levels of all employees below permissible limits.”

Those management measures include:

  • “Strict guideline adherence and safe work protocols,
  • “Increasing staff numbers to decrease exposure duration,
  • “Adoption of engineering solutions such as localized ventilation systems, and
  • “Use of respiratory protective equipment during sample handling and tissue processing.”

Previous Reports on Exposure Risk to Clinical Lab Workers

The knowledge of the danger behind these chemicals isn’t new.

In “National Academy of Sciences Confirms That Formaldehyde Can Cause Cancer in a Finding That Has Implications for Anatomic Pathology and Histology Laboratories,” Dark Daily covered how, in 2011, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) National Toxicology Program’s (NTP) “Report on Carcinogens” was the first instance where formaldehyde was upgraded to “known to be a human carcinogen.”

In 2017, a pathology lab in Auckland, New Zealand, lost its accreditation because formaldehyde levels were so high the lab had to be evacuated nearly every day, The New Zealand Herald reported.

And in “Health of Pathology Laboratory Technicians at Risk from Common Solvents like Xylene and Toluene,” we reported on a 2011 study conducted in Wellington, New Zealand, that linked exposure to these chemicals with increased auto immune connective tissue diseases, notably doubling likelihood of developing Raynaud’s phenomenon.

“In epidemiological studies on industrial workers, pathologists and anatomists, the relationship between exposure to formaldehyde and an increased risk of various types of cancer including nasal cavity, nasopharynx, lung, brain, pancreas, prostate, colon and atopic lymphoma system has been determined,” the Iranian scientists wrote in Nature Scientific Reports.

Call for Stronger Regulations

“The Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), and the Environmental Protection Agency have expressed serious concern about the carcinogenicity of formaldehyde,” the Iranian scientists noted, adding that “the potential carcinogenic risk to humans has been studied in a number of cohort and case-control studies.”

There is room for more studies looking at the health effects of exposure to these chemicals among lab workers, as well as continued evaluation of the risks and preventative measures that could be taken. Perhaps tightened regulations will make its way to US labs, echoing more stringent ones of the European Union.

“It is imperative to implement control measures across various hospital departments to mitigate occupational formaldehyde exposure levels proactively. These findings can be valuable for policymakers in the health sector, aiding in the elimination or reduction of airborne formaldehyde exposure in work environments,” the Iranian scientists wrote.

Managers of histology and clinical laboratories may find useful advice in hospital laboratory studies like that coming out of Iran. Protecting the health of lab workers worldwide starts with reducing their exposure to deadly chemicals.

—Kristin Althea O’Connor

Related Information:

Occupational Exposure, Carcinogenic and Non-Carcinogenic Risk Assessment of Formaldehyde in the Pathology Labs of Hospitals in Iran

National Academy of Sciences Confirms That Formaldehyde Can Cause Cancer in a Finding That Has Implications for Anatomic Pathology and Histology Laboratories

Pathology Lab Loses Accreditation Because of High Levels of Formaldehyde

Health of Pathology Laboratory Technicians at Risk from Common Solvents like Xylene and Toluene

NTRL Report on Carcinogens. Twelfth Edition, 2011

University of Missouri-Kansas City Study Finds Colorectal Cancer Cases Up 500% among Children

Trend will likely lead to physicians ordering more clinical laboratory screening tests for cancer among all age groups, including young patients

Upticks in colorectal cancer cases among younger populations, as reported in recent news stores, is an issue that has implications for clinical laboratories. According to a study conducted at the University of Missouri-Kansas City (UMKC), the number of colorectal cancer cases in the US has increased greatly since 1999 with the “most dramatic jumps” seen in children, teens, and young adults, a Digestive Disease Week (DDW) news release reported.

“Colorectal cancer is no longer considered just a disease of the elderly population,” said lead researcher Islam Mohamed, MD, an internal medicine resident physician at UMKC. “It’s important that the public is aware of signs and symptoms of colorectal cancer.” 

The researchers noted in the DDW news release that “colorectal cancer cases, over about two decades, increased by 500% among children, ages 10 to 14; 333% in teens, ages 15 to 19; and 185% among young adults, ages 20 to 24.”

The UMKC researchers presented their study, “Evolving Trends in Colorectal Cancer Incidence among Patients Under 45: A 22-Year Analysis of the Centers for Disease Control Wonder Database,” at the 2024 Digestive Disease Week conference in May.

DDW is “the largest international gathering of physicians, researchers, and academics in the fields of gastroenterology, hepatology, endoscopy and gastrointestinal surgery. Jointly sponsored by the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases (AASLD), the American Gastroenterological Association (AGA), the American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE) and the Society for Surgery of the Alimentary Tract (SSAT),” the news release states.

“[The results of the UMKC study] means that there is a trend. We don’t know what to make of it yet. It could be lifestyle factors or genetics, but there is a trend,” lead researcher Islam Mohamed, MD (above), Internal Medicine Resident, University of Missouri-Kansas City, told NBC News. If proved, this trend could lead to increased demand for clinical laboratory screening tests for colorectal and other cancers among young people. (Photo copyright: Digestive Disease Week.)

Small Number of Cases, Big Rate of Change

Mohamed and his UMKC research team tapped the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Wonder online database to determine the incidence of colorectal cancer in people aged 10 to 44 from 1999 to 2020. They found that in 2020 cases had reached:

  • 0.6/100,000 children ages 10 to 14 (a 500% increase).
  • 1.3/100,000 teens ages 15 to 19 (a 333% increase).
  • Two/100,000 young adults ages 20 to 24 (a 185% increase).

Albeit small numbers, the cases are growing at a rate that is troublesome, according to experts. As NBC put it, “any increase can take on a larger significance” when rates begin at low points.  

“When you are starting off with a very rare disease in a 15-year-old and you add a couple cases, you are going to have a huge percentage increase,” Folasade May, MD, PhD, Assistant Professor at the David Geffen School of Medicine and an Associate Director of the UCLA Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Equity, told NBC News.

The study also found incidence of colorectal cancer up in people in their 30s and 40s, reaching by 2020:

  • 6.5/100,000 people ages 30 to 34 (a 71% increase).
  • 11.7/100,000 people ages 35 to 39 (a 58% increase).
  • 20/100,000 people ages 40 to 44 (a 37% increase).

Screening Guidelines May Need to Change

Further research based on UMKC’s study findings could lead to changes in cancer screening guidelines.

“We were screening people from the age of 60 for colon cancer. This has now been lowered to 55, and that is due to be lowered again to 50 over the next few months,” Jude Tidbury, RN, nurse endoscopist and clinical nurse specialist, gastroenterology and endoscopy, at the UK’s East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust, told Healthline.

In the US, the American Cancer Society advises people of average risk for cancer to start screening for colorectal cancer at age 45. The test options ACS recommends annually include:

Other Study Findings

What is behind early-onset colorectal cancer among certain age groups? An international study led by Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center (Fred Hutch), Seattle, found “strong correlations” with consuming alcohol and being obese with early-onset colorectal cancer in adults under age 50, according to a news release.

The researchers set out to explore the common genetic variants and causal modifiable risk factors that are behind early-onset colorectal cancer, according to a paper they published in the journal Annals of Oncology.

To do so they used big databases, pulling out 6,176 early-onset colorectal cancer cases and 65,829 controls from sources including:

They then conducted a genome-wide association study and Mendelian randomization analysis to identify causes of early-onset colorectal cancer.

They focused on “lifestyle factors increasing risk” by comparing the genetic variations in those with colorectal cancer to healthy people, the Fred Hutch news release explained.

“It’s important to see that alcohol and obesity are linked to early-onset colorectal cancer. Also, insulin signaling and infection-related biological pathways. These are all really important to understand—it’s helping us to develop interventions,” said Ulrike Peters, PhD, Professor and Associate Director, Public Health Services Division, Fred Hutch, who co-led the research, in the news release.

Peters noted future research may aim to address data gaps relating to racial and ethnic groups.  

More Colorectal Cancer Tests

As studies continue to explore the notion that cancer may not be a disease of aging,

clinical laboratories could see more primary care physicians and healthcare consumers using colorectal cancer screening tests, which require analysis and reporting by labs.

Medical laboratory leaders may want to proactively encourage lab sales and service representatives to educate physician office staff about using the lab’s available resources for screening young adults for colorectal cancer.

—Donna Marie Pocius

Related Information:

Colorectal Cancer Cases More than Tripled among Teens over Two Decades

Evolving Trends in Colorectal Cancer Incidence among Patients Under 45: A 22-Year Analysis of the Centers for Disease Control Wonder Database

Colon Cancer Rates Have Been Rising for Decades in Younger People, Study Finds

Colorectal Cancer Rates Falling in Older Adults but Rising in Children

Study Digs into What’s Driving Early-onset Colon Cancer

Genome-wide Association Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analyses Provide Insights into the Causes of Early-onset Colorectal Cancer

Mass General Brigham Joins with Best Buy Health to Create Country’s Largest Hospital-at-Home Program

Clinical laboratories with mobile phlebotomy programs are positioned to benefit as demand for at-home blood draws increases

Hospital-at-Home (HaH) models of remote healthcare continue to pick up speed. The latest example comes from the 793-bed Mass General Brigham (MGB) health system which partnered with Best Buy Health to build the largest HaH program in the nation, according to Becker’s Hospital Review. This means clinical laboratories will have new opportunities to provide mobile phlebotomy home-draw services for MGB’s HaH patients.

Headquartered in Somerville, Mass., MGB presented its new “Home Hospital” program at the World Medical Innovation Forum (WMIF) in September.

“The health system now has a capacity for acute hospital care at home of 70 patients and is currently treating about 50 to 60 a day. The goal is to move to 10% of Mass General Brigham’s overall capacity, or about 200 to 300 patients,” Becker’s reported.

Best Buy Health provides MGB’s Home Hospital patients with computer tablets and Internet access, Becker’s noted.

“Healthcare is fragmented, the technology doesn’t always connect. Technology is our expertise,” said Chemu Lang’at, COO, Best Buy Health, during the WMIF presentation.

The hospital is the most expensive site of care in the US healthcare industry. Thus, preventing patients from needing to be hospitalized—or treating them in their homes—could reduce the cost of care considerably for both patients and multihospital systems.

“It’s been estimated that 30% of inpatient care will move to the home in the next five years, representing $82 billion in revenue. This is a tremendous opportunity,” said Heather O’Sullivan, MS, RN, A-GNP, Mass General Brigham’s President of Healthcare at Home, during MGB’s presentation at the World Medical Innovation Forum in September, according to Becker’s Hospital Review. MGB’s HaH program offers clinical laboratories with new opportunities to provide mobile phlebotomy services to the health system’s Hospital-at-Home patients. (Photo copyright: Mass General Brigham.)

Hospital-at-Home

Proponents of HaH call it a “sustainable, innovative, and next-generation healthcare model. [It is] person-centered medical care that keeps patients out of the hospital, away from possible complications, and on to better outcomes,” RamaOnHealthcare reported.

Some of the biggest payoffs of HaH include:

• Cost Savings: Anne Klibanski, MD, President and CEO, MGB, described the HaH program as “a way the health system could stay afloat and thrive amid financial challenges affecting the industry, with lower costs and better outcomes for patients at home,” Becker’s Hospital Review reported.

• Increased Capacity: Having an HaH program can help alleviate bed shortages by treating many conditions in patient’s homes rather than in the ER. “The program … typically treats patients with conditions like COPD flare-ups, heart failure exacerbations, acute infections and complex cellulitis,” Becker’s reported.

“It’s not typically comfortable to be cared for in the emergency room,” said O’Neil Britton, MD, MGB’s Chief Integration Officer, at WMIF.

• Decreased Staff Exhaustion: “Clinicians have described getting an extra level of joy from treating patients at home,” said Jatin Dave, MD, CMO, MassHealth, at WMIF. He added that this could provide one solution to healthcare burnout, Becker’s noted.

• Lab Connection: Clinical laboratories have the opportunity to meet the need for mobile phlebotomists to draw blood specimens from HaH patients in their homes.

• Patient Satisfaction: “The data suggests that for populations studied in multiple areas, [HaH] is a safe service with high-quality care, low readmission rates, low escalation rates, low infection rates and—bottom line—patients love it.” Adam Groff, MD, co-founder of Maribel Health, told RamaOnHealthcare.

HaH Program Going Forward

Britton told the WMIF audience that MGB hopes to “expand the program for surgery, oncology, and pain management patients, recently admitting its first colorectal surgery patient,” Becker’s reported.

However, the future of MGB’s HaH program is not assured. “The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) waiver to provide acute hospital care at home expires at the end of 2024. A bill to extend the program recently passed a House committee,” Becker’s reported.

Dave said at WMIF that he “hopes the home will one day provide a ‘single infrastructure’ for all levels of care: from primary to inpatient care to skilled nursing,” Becker’s Hospital Review noted, adding, “The home is where, in the long run, we can have this full continuum.”

Hospital-at-Home programs are not new. In “Best Buy Health and Atrium Health Collaborate on a Hospital-at-Home Program, Leveraging the Electronics Retailer’s ‘Specially Trained’ Geek Squad, Omnichannel Expertise,” Dark Daily covered how Best Buy Health had partnered with 40-hospital Atrium Health in an HaH program that the healthcare system plans to scale nationally.

And in “Orlando Health’s New Hospital-in-the-Home Program Brings Quality Healthcare to Patients in the Comfort of their Homes,” we reported how 3,200-bed Orlando Health had launched its Hospital Care at Home program to provide patients in central Florida acute care outside of traditional hospital settings.

Overall, this can be a snapshot of where the HaH movement in the US is currently at, with the Mass General Brigham example showing that this mode of healthcare is delivering results and helping patients. Clinical laboratories across the nation should track efforts by hospitals and health systems in their areas to establish and expand hospital-at-home programs.

—Kristin Althea O’Connor

Related Information:

How Mass General Brigham Built the Largest ‘Hospital at Home’

‘Society Will Greatly Benefit’ from the Transformative Hospital-at-Home Movement

Are Hospital at Home Programs Forgetting about the Patient?

Best Buy Health and Atrium Health Collaborate on a Hospital-at-Home Program, Leveraging the Electronics Retailer’s ‘Specially Trained’ Geek Squad, Omnichannel Expertise

Orlando Health’s New Hospital-in-the-Home Program Brings Quality Healthcare to Patients in the Comfort of their Homes

Keio University and Broad Institute Researchers Identify 18 Bacterial Strains That Could Help Patients with Gastrointestinal Illnesses

Findings could lead to new therapies and clinical laboratory biomarkers for detecting and defeating antibiotic-resistant bacteria

Once again, new research shows that human gut bacteria (microbiota) may be useful in fighting antibiotic-resistant bacterial infections. The study findings could provide new therapeutics and clinical laboratory biomarkers for diagnosing and treating severe gastrointestinal disorders.

Researchers at Keio University School of Medicine in Tokyo and the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard have identified a unique combination of 18 bacterial strains that could aid in combatting a particularly nasty bacteria called Enterobacteriaceae, the cause of several intestinal conditions such as inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), according to a news release.

Antibiotic-resistant bacterial infections often appear in patients with chronic intestinal conditions and in those with long-term antibiotic use. Enterobacteriaceae is a large family of gram-negative bacteria that includes more than 30 genera and over 100 species.

“Despite two decades of microbiome research, we are just beginning to understand how to define health-promoting features of the gut microbiome,” said Marie-Madlen Pust, PhD, a computational postdoctoral researcher at the Broad Institute and co-first author of the paper, in the news release.

“Part of the challenge is that each person’s microbiome is unique. This collaborative effort allowed us to functionally characterize the different mechanisms of action these bacteria use to reduce pathogen load and gut inflammation,” she added.

The researchers identified a way to treat patients infected by antibiotic-resistant strains of bacteria that does not involve antibiotics. Should further research validate these early findings, this could be a viable approach to treating patients with this condition.

They published their findings titled, “Commensal Consortia Decolonize Enterobacteriaceae via Ecological Control” in the peer-reviewed, scientific journal Nature.

“Microbiome studies can often consist of analyzing collections of genetic sequences, without understanding what each gene does or why certain microbes are beneficial,” said Ramnik Xavier, MD (above), director of Broad Institute’s immunology program, co-director of the infectious disease and microbiome program, and co-senior author on the study, in a news release. “Trying to uncover that function is the next frontier, and this is a nice first step towards figuring out how microbial metabolites influence health and inflammation.” Clinical laboratories that test for intestinal conditions caused by antibiotic resistance will want to follow the Broad Institute’s research. (Photo copyright: Broad Institute.)

Suppressing Growth of Antibiotic-resistant Bacteria

To perform their research, the scientists isolated about 40 strains of bacteria from the stools of five healthy fecal donors. They then used those stool samples in fecal microbiota transplants to treat mice that had been infected with either Escherichia coli (E. coli) or Klebsiella, both forms of Enterobacteriaceae. The scientists tested different combinations of the 40 strains and identified 18 that suppressed the growth of Enterobacteriaceae.

“Antibiotic-resistant Enterobacteriaceae such as E. coli and Klebsiella bacteria are common in hospitals, where they can proliferate in the gut of patients and cause dangerous systemic infections that are difficult to treat. Some research suggests that Enterobacteriaceae also perpetuates inflammation in the intestine and infection by other microbes,” the Broad Institute news release notes.

The researchers discovered that Klebsiella changed the gene expression in carbohydrate uptake and metabolism in the Klebsiella-infected mice that were treated with the 18 beneficial strains. The gene expression included the downregulating of gluconate kinase and transporter genes, which revealed there is increased competition among gut bacteria for nutrients. 

When combined, these 18 strains alleviated inflammation in the guts of the treated mice by depriving the harmful gut bacteria of carbohydrates. This non-antibiotic approach also prevented harmful bacteria from colonizing in the gut. 

“In partnership with the Broad’s Metabolomics Platform, led by senior director and study co-author Clary Clish, PhD, they analyzed samples from pediatric patients with ulcerative colitis, looking for the presence of alternate gluconate pathway genes of gut microbes and fecal gluconate levels. They found higher levels of gluconate linked to more gluconate-consuming Enterobacteriaceae in samples from pediatric patients with ongoing inflammation, indicated by high levels of the protein calprotectin,” the study authors wrote in Nature.

“Together, the findings suggest that Enterobacteriaceae processes gluconate as a key nutrient and contributes to inflammation in patients. But when a gut microbiome includes the 18 helpful strains, they likely compete with Enterobacteriaceae for gluconate and other nutrient sources, limiting the proliferation of the harmful bacteria,” the scientists concluded.

Promising New Bacterial Therapies

This research could ultimately lead to the development of fecal microbiota transplants for individuals to eradicate antibiotic-resistant bacteria in a more objective and specific manner, with fewer side effects than current treatments. 

“Harnessing these activities in the form of live bacterial therapies may represent a promising solution to combat the growing threat of proinflammatory, antimicrobial-resistant Enterobacteriaceae infection,” the scientists wrote in Nature.

According to the news release, they plan to continue research to “uncover the identity and function of unknown metabolites that contribute to gut health and inflammation.” The team hopes to discover how different bacteria compete with each other, and to develop microbial therapeutics that improve gut microbiome and curb bacterial infections.

More studies are needed to prove the efficacy of this type of fecal bacterial treatment. However, this research demonstrates how using nano processes enabled by new technologies to identify the actual work of proteins, RNA, and DNA in the body cheaply, faster, and with greater precision, will open doors to both therapeutic and diagnostic clinical laboratory biomarkers.  

—JP Schlingman

Related Information:

Scientists Identify a Unique Combination of Bacterial Strains That Could Treat Antibiotic-resistant Gut Infections

Commensal Consortia Decolonize Enterobacteriaceae via Ecological Control

Combination of Bacterial Strains Could Potentially Treat Antibiotic-Resistant Gut Infections

Stanford University Scientists Discover New Lifeform Residing in Human Microbiome

Researchers Use Ingestible Device to Non-Invasively Sample Human Gut Bacteria in a Development That Could Enable More Clinical Laboratory Testing of Microbiomes

Genetic Tests Are Detecting Prevalence of Bird Flu Virus in US Wastewater and Allowing Officials to Track its Spread

Though PCR clinical laboratory testing is widely used, some scientists are concerned its specificity may limit the ability to identify all variants of bird flu in wastewater

Wastewater testing of infectious agents appears to be here to stay. At the same time, there are differences of opinion about which methodologies and clinical laboratory tests are best suited to screen for specific contagions in wastewater. One such contagion is avian influenza, the virus that causes bird flu.

Wastewater testing by public health officials became a valuable tool during the COVID-19 pandemic and has now become a common method for detecting other diseases as well. For example, earlier this year, scientists used wastewater testing to learn how the H5N1 variant of the bird flu virus was advancing among dairy herds across the country.

In late March, the bird flu was first detected in dairy cattle in Texas, prompting scientists to begin examining wastewater samples to track the virus. Some researchers, however, expressed concerns about the ability of sewage test assays to detect all variants of certain diseases.

“Right now we are using these sort of broad tests to test for influenza A viruses,” Denis Nash, PhD, Distinguished Professor of Epidemiology at City University of New York (CUNY) and Executive Director of CUNY’s Institute for Implementation Science in Population Health (SPH), told the Los Angeles Times. “It’s possible there are some locations around the country where the primers being used in these tests might not work for H5N1.” Clinical laboratory PCR genetic testing is most commonly used to screen for viruses in wastewater. (Photo copyright: CUNY SPH.)

Effectiveness of PCR Wastewater Testing

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests are most commonly used to distinguish genetic material related to a specific illness such as the flu virus. For PCR tests to correctly identify a virus, the tests must be designed to look for a specific subtype. The two most prevalent human influenza A viruses are known as H1N1 (swine flu) and H3N2, which was responsible for the 1968 pandemic that killed a million people worldwide. The “H” stands for hemagglutinin and the “N” for neuraminidase.

Hemagglutinin is a glycoprotein that assists the virus to attach to and infect host cells. Neuraminidase is an enzyme found in many pathogenic or symbiotic microorganisms that separates the links between neuraminic acids in various molecules.

Avian flu is also an influenza A virus, but it has the subtype H5N1. Although human and bird flu viruses both contain the N1 signal, they do not share an H. Some scientists fear that—in cases where a PCR test only looks for H1 and H3 in wastewater—that test could miss the bird flu altogether.

“We don’t have any evidence of that. It does seem like we’re at a broad enough level that we don’t have any evidence that we would not pick up H5,” Jonathan Yoder, Deputy Director, Infectious Disease Readiness and Innovation at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) told the Los Angeles Times.

The CDC asserts current genetic testing methods are standardized and will detect the bird flu. Yoder also affirmed the tests being used at all the testing sites are the same assay, based on information the CDC has published regarding testing for influenza A viruses. 

Genetic Sequencing Finds H5N1 in Texas Wastewater

In an article published on the preprint server medRxiv titled, “Virome Sequencing Identifies H5N1 Avian Influenza in Wastewater from Nine Cities,” the authors wrote, “using an agnostic, hybrid-capture sequencing approach, we report the detection of H5N1 in wastewater in nine Texas cities, with a total catchment area population in the millions, over a two-month period from March 4th to April 25th, 2024.”

The authors added, “Although human to human transmission is rare, infection has been fatal in nearly half of patients who have contracted the virus in past outbreaks. The increasing presence of the virus in domesticated animals raises substantial concerns that viral adaptation to immunologically naïve humans may result in the next flu pandemic.”

“So, it’s not just targeting one virus—or one of several viruses—as one does with PCR testing,” Eric Boerwinkle, PhD, Dean of the UTHealth Houston School of Public Health told the LA Times. “We’re actually in a very complex mixture, which is wastewater, pulling down viruses and sequencing them. What’s critical here is it’s very specific to H5N1.”

Epidemiologist Blake Hanson, PhD, Assistant Professor, Department of Epidemiology, Human Genetics, and Environmental Sciences at the UT Health Houston Graduate School of Biomedical Science, agreed with Boerwinkle that though the PCR-based methodology is highly effective at detecting avian flu in wastewater samples, the testing can do more.

“We have the ability to look at the representation of the entire genome, not just a marker component of it. And so that has allowed us to look at H5N1, differentiate it from some of our seasonal fluids like H1N1 and H3N2,” Hanson told the LA Times. “It’s what gave us high confidence that it is entirely H5N1, whereas the other papers are using a part of the H5 gene as a marker for H5.”

Human or Animal Sources

Both Boerwinkle and Hanson are epidemiologists in the team studying wastewater samples for H5N1 in Texas. They are not sure where the virus originated but are fairly certain it did not come from humans.

“Texas is really a confluence of a couple of different flyways for migratory birds, and Texas is also an agricultural state, despite having quite large cities,” Boerwinkle noted. “It’s probably correct that if you had to put your dime and gamble what was happening, it’s probably coming from not just one source but from multiple sources. We have no reason to think that one source is more likely any one of those things.”

“Because we are looking at the entirety of the genome, when we look at the single human H5N1 case, the genomic sequence has a hallmark amino acid change, compared to all of the cattle from that same time point,” Hanson said. “We do not see that hallmark amino acid present in any of our sequencing data. And we’ve looked very carefully for that, which gives us some confidence that we’re not seeing human-human transmission.”

CDC Updates on Bird Flu

In its weekly updates on the bird flu situation, the CDC reported that 48 states have outbreaks in poultry and 14 states have avian flu outbreaks in dairy cows. More than 238 dairy herds have been affected and, as of September 20, over 100 million poultry have been affected by the disease.

In addition, the CDC monitored more than 4,900 people who came into contact with an infected animal. Though about 230 of those individuals have been tested for the disease, there have only been a total of 14 reported human cases in the US.

The CDC posts information specifically for laboratory workers, healthcare providers, and veterinarians on its website.

The CDC also states that the threat from avian flu to the general public is low. Individuals at an increased risk for infection include people who work around infected animals and those who consume products containing raw, unpasteurized cow’s milk.

Symptoms of H5N1 in humans may include fever or chills, cough, headaches, muscle or body aches, runny or stuffy nose, tiredness and shortness of breath. Symptoms typically surface two to eight days after exposure.

Scientists and researchers have been seeking a reliable clinical laboratory test for disease organisms in a fast, accurate, and cost-effective manner. Wastewater testing of infectious agents could fulfill those goals and appears to be a technology that will continue to be used for tracking disease.

—JP Schlingman

Related Information:

As National Wastewater Testing Expands, Texas Researchers Identify Bird Flu in Nine Cities

Experts Blast CDC over Failure to Test Sewage for Signs of H5N1 Bird Flu Virus

From Sewage to Safety: Hospital Wastewater Surveillance as a Beacon for Defense Against H5N1 Bird Flu

The Bird Flu Outbreak Has Spread to Humans: Are We Too Late to Prevent the Next Pandemic?

Detection of Hemagglutinin H5 Influenza A Virus Sequence in Municipal Wastewater Solids at Wastewater Treatment Plants with Increases in Influenza A in Spring, 2024

Virome Sequencing Identifies H5N1 Avian Influenza in Wastewater from Nine Cities

Wastewater Analysis Continues to Be an Effective Tool for Tracking Deadly Infectious Diseases in Human Communities

Genetic Testing of Wastewater Now Common in Detecting New Strains of COVID-19 and Other Infectious Diseases

San Francisco International Airport First in the Nation to Test Wastewater for SARS-CoV-2 Coronavirus

New, Cryptic COVID-19 Lineage Found in Ohio Wastewater by Molecular Virologist Tracking Spread of SARS-CoV-2 Variants

Washington University Researchers Uses Medical Laboratory Test Results and Big Data to Find Accelerated Aging and Risk of Early Cancer in Young Adults

Study shows that computer analysis of clinical laboratory test results has improved greatly in recent years

Studies using “big data” continue to show how combining different types of healthcare information can generate insights not available with smaller datasets. In this case, researchers at Washington University School of Medicine (WashU Medicine), St. Louis, Mo., determined that—by using the results from nine different types of clinical laboratory tests—they could correlate those test results to younger people who had “aged faster” and had developed cancer earlier than usual, according to CNN.

“Accumulating evidence suggests that the younger generations may be aging more swiftly than anticipated, likely due to earlier exposure to various risk factors and environmental insults. However, the impact of accelerated aging on early-onset cancer development remains unclear,” said Ruiyi Tian, PhD candidate at WashU Medicine’s Yin Cao Lab in an American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) news release.

The scientists presented their findings, which have not yet been published, at the AACR’s annual meeting held in April. Tian and the other researchers “hypothesized that increased biological age, indicative of accelerated aging, may contribute to the development of early-onset cancers, often defined as cancers diagnosed in adults younger than 55 years. In contrast to chronological age—which measures how long a person has been alive—biological age refers to the condition of a person’s body and physiological processes and is considered modifiable,” AACR noted in a news release.

“We all know cancer is an aging disease. However, it is really coming to a younger population. So, whether we can use the well-developed concept of biological aging to apply that to the younger generation is a really untouched area,” Yin Cao, ScD MPH (above), associate professor of surgery and associate professor of medicine at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, and senior author of the study, told CNN. Analysis of clinical laboratory test results using computer algorithms continues to show value for new research into deadly diseases. (Photo copyright: Washington University.)

Lab Tests Share Insights about Aging

To acquire the data they needed for their research, the WashU Medicine scientists turned to the UK Biobank, a biomedical and research resource with genetic and health information on half a million UK residents.

The researchers reviewed the medical records of 148,724 biobank participants, age 37 to 54, focusing on nine blood-based biomarkers that “have been shown to correlate with biological age,” CNN reported. Those biomarkers are:

According to CNN, the researchers “plugged” the nine values into an algorithm called PhenoAge. Using the algorithm they compared the biological ages with each person’s actual chronological age to determine “accelerated aging.” They then consulted cancer registries to capture data on those in the study who were diagnosed with cancer before age 55. They found 3,200 cases.

Young Adults Aging Faster than Earlier Generations

According to the AACR news release, the WashU Medicine study found that:

  • “Individuals born in or after 1965 had a 17% higher likelihood of accelerated aging than those born between 1950 and 1954.
  • “Each standard deviation increase in accelerated aging was associated with a 42% increased risk of early-onset lung cancer, a 22% increased risk of early-onset gastrointestinal cancer, and a 36% increased risk of early-onset uterine cancer.
  • “Accelerated aging did not significantly impact the risk of late-onset lung cancer (defined here as cancer diagnosed after age 55), but it was associated with a 16% and 23% increased risk of late-onset gastrointestinal and uterine cancers, respectively.”

“We speculate that common pathways, such as chronic inflammation and cellular senescence, may link accelerated aging to the development of early-onset cancers,” the study’s principal investigator Yin Cao, ScD, MPH, associate professor of surgery and associate professor of medicine at WashU Medicine, told The Hill.

“Historically, both cancer and aging have been viewed primarily as concerns for older populations. The realization that cancer, and now aging, are becoming significant issues for younger demographics over the past decades was unexpected,” Tian told Fox News.

More Screenings, Further Analysis

The study’s results may suggest a change in clinical laboratory screenings for younger people.

“We see cancers earlier all the time now, and nobody knows why. The subset in the population that has accelerated aging may need screening more often or earlier,” Emanuela Taioli, MD, PhD, professor of population health and science and of thoracic surgery, and director of the Institute for Translational Epidemiology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, told Health.

In future studies, WashU Medicine scientists may aim to include groups of greater diversity and explore why people are aging faster and have risk of early-onset cancers. 

“There is room to improve using better technologies. Looking at the bigger picture, the aging concept can be applied to younger people to include cancers, cardiovascular disease, and diabetes,” Cao told Discover Magazine.

While more research is needed, use of the UK’s Biobank of healthcare data—including clinical laboratory test results—enabled the WashU Medicine researchers to determine that accelerated aging among young adults is happening with some regularity. This shows that capabilities in computer analysis are gaining more refined capabilities and are able to tease out insights impossible to achieve with earlier generations of analytical software.

These findings should inspire clinical laboratory professionals and pathologists to look for opportunities to collaborate in healthcare big data projects involving their patients and the communities they serve.

—Donna Marie Pocius

Related Information:

Accelerated Aging May Increase the Risk of Early-onset Cancers in Younger Generations

Accelerated Aging Linked to Cancer Risk in Younger Adults, Research Shows

An Epigenetic Biomarker of Aging for Lifespan and Health Span in Aging

Accelerated Aging May be a Cause of Increased Cancers in People under 55

Cancer Rates Rising in Young People Due to “Accelerated Aging,” New Study Finds

Research Shows Accelerated Aging Linked to Increased Cancer Risk in Younger Adults

Rate of Biological Aging is Accelerating in Young People, Leading to Medical Issues

;